The Best Cookie Sandwiches Recipes for Your Sweet Tooth

No matter which time of the day, what time of the year, or which occasion or event, cookie sandwiches are something that always speaks to our hearts! You can be an adult or a five-year-old child, and the emotions about cookie sandwiches remain unchanged! And since you are here reading this article, we get it that you are a die-heart fan of it too! But before we get started with preparing them let's quickly glance through the origin of the cookies! It is rather intriguing to learn about the creator of this bunch of cookies!

History of cream cookie sandwiches

This is to be noted that ice cream sandwiches have been around for decades and with every passing day, new and unique variations are coming up! From squares to circles, patterned to what not! The options are simply endless when it comes to cookie sandwiches. Today if you check the cookie or the biscuit section of the supermarket then you must have noticed different brands and companies coming up with more and more ideas every other day! Filled with all sorts of cream, you can buy a bunch of them! Or not? Because when you can make them at home then why spend money at the stores?

But you shall be shocked to find out that before the 1800s, the term sandwich cookies or ice cream sandwiches did not even exist. Back in those days, the entire sandwich was not fully edible as two inedible sheets of paper held them together.

The first cookie sandwich came up in 1928!

George Whitney was the creator of the oatmeal sandwich cookies for the first time in the history of the human race! We couldn't be more thankful for his brilliant idea. This took place in San Francisco where a layer of vanilla ice cream was sandwiched between two layers of oatmeal cookies and then wrapped in liquid chocolate.

Around twenty years later, the modern chocolate cookie sandwiches slowly marked their emergence. Jerry Newberg was credited for the creation of these cookies which he sold at baseball games in Pittsburgh in 1945. On the other hand, Richard LaMotta claims to be the creator of the ice cream sandwich made with chocolate chip cookies and chocolate chip ice cream. Via street cart vendors, he started selling them initially on the roads of Manhattan! And do you know what happened, 25,000 such sandwiches( known as Chipwich) were sold within just a few hours?

Tips for making sandwich cookies at home

• The cookie is the base of the sandwich cookies- the cookies are supposed to be the base of the sandwich cookies and hence you calmly make them too soggy! Baking must be done carefully! However, being too tough can make it hard to munch on the cookies and experience the delicious filling inside.
• Should you drizzle chocolate chips in the cookie dough? No matter how much in love you are with chocolate chips, we recommend you avoid them! Do you know why? This is because the drastic shift in temperature from hot oven to cold freezer is something that the chocolate chips can not tolerate and as a result, the cookies turn out to be so hard.
• Allow ample resting time- when you are making a cookie sandwich, allow the cookie dough to rest in the refrigerator for twelve hours or at least overnight. This helps the dough to absorb the liquid and turn firm.

Now, let's have a look at all the amazing sandwich cookie recipes that await you! Let's begin.

Delicious Cookie Sandwiches: Delicious Recipes for the Perfect Snack

1. Chewy Peanut butter Reese's sandwich

The crumbly crust outside holding the smooth peanut butter cream inside tastes so marvelous indeed!

Rich and crumbly, you are definitely going to love this idea! Go for it already!

2. Polish lemon sandwich tea cookies

Traditional Polish cookies never fail to leave up smitten! Zesty and savory, the cookies are drizzled with sugar dust with a gorgeous filling inside.

You are definitely going to fall in love with this extraordinary treat during the holidays. Try it out today!

3. Brownie cookie sandwich

If you are in the mood for something succulent and sweet then go ahead with the brownie cookie sandwich!

Delicious and crumbly, the idea for the cookies is lovely and flooded with great vanilla essence. So what are you waiting for?

4. Peanut butter and jelly sandwich cookies

Not just one layer of cream but in fact two to one's surprise! The combination of jelly and peanut butter is wonderful within the crumbly and crunchy cookies outside.

So shall we try out this one? Make some for us too!

5. Lemon dream cookies

There is nothing so divine as compared to the taste of lemon cookies! Indeed a dream come true for dessert lovers!

Drizzled with sugar, the shiny and shimmering cookies are so easy to make! So try them out today!

6. Funfetti sandwich cookies with cheese cream frosting( olive + thyme)

The vibrant Funfetti sandwich with a thick layer of cream cheese frosting is waiting for you right here!

All you need to do is follow the steps in the recipe and bake yourself some detectable treats.

The subtle essence of olive and thyme is also palpable.

7. Cute as a button cream wafer

The vibrant and colorful button-cream wafer will steal the show the moment they are displayed in front of the guests!

In fact, you have to make more because they will not last the holidays! How can something so delicious be resisted for long?

8. Homemade Oreo sandwich cookies

Creamy, rich, and savory, the homemade Oreo sandwiches are way better than the store-bought ones!

You have to agree with us once you try them out! Crunchy outside and milky inside.

9. Caramel apple stuffed cookies

We are talking about the lovely caramel apple stuffed cookies which have no parallel!

Delectable and gooey, you must give it a try for sure. The combination of caramel and apple always stands out for us.

10. Soft-made golden Oreos

The classic Oreo cookies have a twist waiting for you! Delicious and rich, the soft and tender golden Oreo cookies are one of a kind!

Try them out this holiday season and be ready to be bewitched at the very first bite.

11. Soft and chewy lemon sugar cookie sandwich

The soft and tender lemon sugar cookies are exciting for both kids and adults!

Splendid and creamy, the zestful essence of the cookies makes you crave more and more.

So what are you waiting for? Make it right away!

12. Snickerdoodle Sandwich cookies

We all are quite fond of snickerdoodle cookies and so we decided to add it to the list!

Now that you have the instructions at your fingertip, do not forget to indulge in its blissful taste.

Go for it already!

13. Vanilla bean sandwich cookies with strawberry buttercream and brown butter blondie

The smooth and cozy vanilla bean sandwich cookies are comforting and luxurious in every bite!

Full of buttercream and brown butter, the idea turns out to be the highlight of the season.

14. Red velvet sandwich cookies with cream cheese frosting

The wondrous red velvet sandwich cookies are exactly what we have been looking for to brighten up your days.

Filled with cream cheese, the recipe turns out to be an extraordinary treat for dessert lovers. Shall we then?

15. Chocolate raspberry sandwich cookies

The combination of chocolate and raspberry is incredible and if you haven't tried it out yet, then all we have to say is that you are majorly missing out on something marvelous.

So dig in your hands and get started with the prep!

16. Pineapple cookie sandwiches

It is the look of the pineapple cookies which leaves one completely smitten!

Delicious and cozy, if you are fond of the pineapple flavor then go ahead with this one already!

Such an elegant treat for the holiday season.

17. Incredible gingerbread oatmeal cream cheese cookie pies

We are confused about whether it is a pie or a sandwich! So we decided to call them both!

The recipe is so rich in flavors and leaves one tempted for more and more! Go for this one already!

18. Reese's sandwich cookies

The magnificent Reese's sandwich cookies are indeed an incredible choice if you are wondering which one can you bake this season!

Delicious and crunchy, the kids might loiter around the kitchen looking for the treats to get ready!

Shall we begin then?

19. Dulce De leche cookies

Although the name might sound complicated, the taste and the look of the cookies will compel you to make them again and again!

If you plan to serve these to the guests with tea in the evening, then rest assured you will be showered with words of praise.

20. The lemon sandwich cookies

If it has to be sandwich cookies then it has to be the classic lemon sandwich cookies!

The zesty and lemony essence is what draws us towards these cookies again and again! Make them for sure.

Conclusion

When it comes to satisfying your sweet tooth, there's nothing better than a delicious cookie sandwich. Whether you opt for the classic Oreo and ice cream combination or decide to get creative with a homemade peanut butter and jelly cookie sandwich, these recipes offer a perfect balance of texture and flavor. Of course, you can always put your own spin on any of these recipes to make them even more unique and delicious. So let your taste buds be your guide as you explore the world of cookie sandwich recipes and find the one that speaks to you.

In the end, cookie sandwiches offer a fun and simple way to indulge your cravings and end a meal on a sweet note. As William J. Clinton once said, “Life is too short not to be tense, but also too short to miss out on the joy of cookies and cream.” So grab your ingredients and get baking – your sweet tooth will thank you for it.